![]() |
|
6mm Grendel Group Design Project - Printable Version +- 6.5 Grendel Forum (https://65grendel.com) +-- Forum: GENERAL FIREARMS DISCUSSION (https://65grendel.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=38) +--- Forum: Cartridges (https://65grendel.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=18) +--- Thread: 6mm Grendel Group Design Project (/showthread.php?tid=14502) |
6mm Grendel Group Design Project - bj139 - 11-19-2017 hill37 Wrote:As I understand it, smaller diameter=longer bullet for the same weight=higher BC. Right? I know but is this difference large enough to have a meaningful improvement in performance? 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - StoneHendge - 11-19-2017 bj139 Wrote:Is this really worth doing for 0.020" less diameter? The best long range target bullet for 6.5 Grendel is the 123 Scenar with a G7 of .264 (my opinion). With a 6mm Grendel, you can push a 105 RDF a lot faster (same case capacity) and it has a .280 G7 (or 105 Berger Hybrid with a .275 G7). In comparison, I do a 130 gr Norma GT with a G7 of .285 at 2800 out of my 24" 6.5 CM. I got over 2900 with factory Prime ammo (same bullet), but that stuff is hot. 2800 should be attainable with a 24" 6mm Grendel (even more with BFT's bigger case), so it really would be nipping at the S'more's heels - from a small frame. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - SHORT-N-SASSY - 11-19-2017 bj139 Wrote:I know but is this difference large enough to have a meaningful improvement in performance? In my view, it's a whole new ballgame --- ![]() (http://www.65grendel.com/forum/showthread.php?15189-Current-6mm-Grendel-barrel-makers-BHW-McGowen-and-who-else&p=170192&viewfull=1#post170192 Particularly, in view of the all-new CMMG ANVIL action, with their "take no prisoners" POWERBOLT --- ![]() (http://www.65grendel.com/forum/showthread.php?14838-CMMG-6-5-Grendel&p=165540&viewfull=1#post165540) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ETA: ![]() (http://www.rifleshootermag.com/uncategorized/6-5-grendel-evolution/) Enter: The 6mm Grendel Improved, the obvious next step in the Grendel Evolution --- and, with improved ballistic superiority, further separates us from the 6.8 crowd. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - CavityBackBullets - 11-19-2017 As a bullet designer that has done a lot of work personally pushing different calibers to their upper limits. You cannot look at case capacity alone. You also have to look at available pressure. Available pressure and time under the pressure curve is what makes bullets go faster. Of course that speaking of internal ballistics and not including rifling profiles, engraving friction and bore lining. Another thing that is seldom mentioned is the width of the shoulder and how it effects pressure when looking for maximum performance. This is why Weatherby used the rounded shoulder they did. I am working with a long range bolt rifle company that has went to the Weatherby shoulder in a new cartridge they are designing due to less pressure spiking. This is also one reason the 30 Herrett can push a 125 grain bullet 2791 FPS from an 18in barrel. Now granted it does not have the high BC you all love, however it does speak to what I am pointing out. There is a new TAC6 coming out on the 6.8 case. With the current support by Nosler and Federal on 6.8 case based cats it may be worth looking at. I do not think pushing the 6mmAR shoulder forward such a small amount will gain what your looking for. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - K_4c - 11-19-2017 Less felt recoil, high bc projectiles, faster MV.... I'll take a 6mm over a 6.5 givin the Grendel's case capacity anyday. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - StoneHendge - 11-20-2017 CavityBackBullets Wrote:As a bullet designer that has done a lot of work personally pushing different calibers to their upper limits. So TAC6 = 6x6.8? Seems like i should wait for a TAC6ii.
6mm Grendel Group Design Project - m796rider - 11-20-2017 What about terminal ballistics? I see 6mm projectiles dominate PRS and other LR competitions, but are they useful for hunting medium sized game? One of the nice things about Grendel is the immense body of data around the effectiveness of 6.5mm projectiles in harvesting game. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - K_4c - 11-20-2017 6mm's have been harvesting medium sized game for years. Also allows for lighter loads for thin skinned animals. Light recoil, flat trajectory, etc... barrel life is its only major draw back. But if you're burning out barrels, cost of ammo exceeded the barrel and smith work roughly by 2x -3x's. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - LRRPF52 - 11-20-2017 CavityBackBullets Wrote:As a bullet designer that has done a lot of work personally pushing different calibers to their upper limits.More case capacity with the optimum powder density and burn rate will result in higher mv. The term you're looking for on the Weatherby design is called a "double radius". The 6mm AR Turbo is used for this reason over the 6mm AR. The shorter, fatter powder column in a Grendel or BR-type case will burn more efficiently than an early 1900's type 30 Remington-based case. It's one of the reasons you see 6.5 Grendel at lower working pressure getting the same speeds as a 6.8 case with the same bullet weight pushed to higher pressures. It makes no sense at all to use a lower capacity case with inferior shaping to it when we're trying to get more mv, especially with the lower bore volume of a 6mm. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - bj139 - 11-20-2017 m796rider Wrote:What about terminal ballistics? I see 6mm projectiles dominate PRS and other LR competitions, but are they useful for hunting medium sized game? K_4c Wrote:6mm's have been harvesting medium sized game for years. Also allows for lighter loads for thin skinned animals. Light recoil, flat trajectory, etc... barrel life is its only major draw back. But if you're burning out barrels, cost of ammo exceeded the barrel and smith work roughly by 2x -3x's. If you are punching paper at long range this looks to be a good idea but for game animals I don't know. Larger 6mms (243win, 6mm rem) have higher velocity to compensate for the lighter bullet. 223s have been used to take thin skinned game as well but I don't think it is a good idea. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - K_4c - 11-21-2017 It's not uncommon to see 6mm Grendel's driving 105 class projectiles to 2750 and 90/95 grains to 2820+ fps. I run the 95 tmks at 2800 FPS and I've still got 1070 ft-lb at 350 yards and 1.1 mil elevation. My 6.5 Grendel running 123 eld's at 2540 FPS, 1067 ft-lb at 350 and 1.5 mil... If I needed more HP, I'd grab my 6 dasher, 6xc, 7rem mag or 300 Norma. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - SHORT-N-SASSY - 11-21-2017 bj139 Wrote:If you are punching paper at long range this looks to be a good idea but for game animals I don't know. From my personal experience, I have taken Colorado Mule Deer with one-shot kills using a Remington Model 660 Carbine (20" barrel) chambered for the 6mm Remington, using Remington factory-loaded 6mm Remington Hi-Speed 100-grain Pointed Soft Point CoreLokt ammunition. Compare the downrange velocity and energy values of the 6mm AR Turbo 40 Improved, with the Sierra 110-grain HPBT Matchking projectile (BC - 0.617) (A) and the factory-loaded 6mm Remington, with the Remington 100-grain Pointed Soft Point CoreLokt projectile (BC - 0.356) (B) out to 1,000 yards, with a 10 mph crosswind, from 24" barrels: ![]() 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - bj139 - 11-21-2017 SNS, Good chart showing there is very little difference between the 6mm Rem and 6mm AR turbo improved. The name "6mm AR turbo improved" is too long to be a viable cartridge. ![]() After buying a Howa mini Grendel, I am bitten by the 6mm bolt gun bug and am looking into aquiring one instead of more ARs.. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - JASmith - 11-21-2017 Provided the bullet impacts within its design envelope for expansion, the performance is independent of caliber for bullets of the same weight and design. That means we should see little difference in performance on game with 100 gr-class bullets whether we are looking at 6mm, 6.5mm or .277 mm caliber, except for how far out the bullet will still be effective. The questions of bullet weight, caliber and velocity are explored in some detail here. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - 454bore - 11-23-2017 If you want to design a 6mm grendel that has a chance at becoming a factory round stick with the 30 degree shoulder so you don't have to do anything except a simple neck down. Blown out wildcats only gain around 100 fps with a 26 inch barrel. Mine is 22 inch and anything longer doesn't make for a hunting rig I'd want to carry. What I like most about my 6mm grendel is the accuracy can be incredibly better than most calibers. Short fat cases with 30 degree shoulders have provided this over and over for a long time. 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - Texas - 11-23-2017 The 6mm ppc, 6mm AR, and 6mm AR Turbo have significant development history and the 6mm PPC has been tweaked for accuracy. Without reworking the bolt and barrel extension to allow for higher pressure it is academic 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - CavityBackBullets - 11-23-2017 LRRPF52 Wrote:More case capacity with the optimum powder density and burn rate will result in higher mv. Lets just agree to disagree since I shoot them all. Do you? 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - grayfox - 11-25-2017 This thread has been some good reading for me with lots of back and forth debate. I do have one request, could someone summarize where we stand currently with the case/chamber design for this project? If there are 2 competing, leading concepts, that's fine too - I just want to see a "score card" of the design so far that basically lets everyone know where the concept stands as of now... Note, this is not to say that it's all finished design-wise (unless that is true), just a recap to say this is where it stands right now. Thanks! 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - StoneHendge - 11-25-2017 Well there could be a lucky soul out there if they haven't spent all of their Black Friday money yet. Looks like McGowen actually has a 24" 6mm Grrrr in stock and ready to ship http://mcgowenbarrel.com/shop/ar15-6mm-grendel-hbar-750-rifle-length-24-polished-ss/ Just let me know how it shoots while I wait for mine. And if you're a lurker, create an account lol Edit: wtf? Clicked link after posting to confirm it worked - looks like it has 1/2" muzzle threads? 6mm Grendel Group Design Project - SHORT-N-SASSY - 11-25-2017 Now that Hornady has finally offered our shooting world their version of the outstanding short-action 6.5mm GAP 4S SAUM long-range cartridge: the Hornady 6.5mm PRC (Precision Rifle Cartridge). I look forward to Hornady's version of the hot 6mm AR Turbo 40 Improved, for AR-15-length platforms. |