A bad day at the range, beats a great day at the office.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • cory
    Chieftain
    • Jun 2012
    • 2987

    A bad day at the range, beats a great day at the office.

    I took a trip to the range today for the fist time since late last fall. After about an hour of shooting, I was about ready to tear my rifle down and rebuild her making sure everything was torqued. It was the first time I've used my suppressor on a warmer day (72F). I suspect the suppressor heating up was affecting my accuracy. I'll need to do further testing on a better day to verify.

    The winds were gnarly to say the least. For the most part it was half value winds with large gusts between at the bench, between the 100 yard and 200 yard berm, between the 200 yard and 300 yard berm, or some combination. The winds were acting like a bipolar.schizophrenic girlfriend at that week. It was constantly changing directions.

    I ran into an experienced guy at the range and told him what I was expecting. He said he'd experienced days like that at this range were he got similar results due to the wind. I'll go try a different place to shoot before I blame the rifle.

    I was shooting almost exclusively Hornady factory AMAX other than some load work. I only tracked the velocity of a small sample of what I shoot, but none the less I got a huge STD (40 fps) in velocity.
    2427 2467 2398 2375 2381 2450 2473 2470

    This was an early 200 yard target. POAs were all over the place, not just dead center of any target.


    I discarded the suppressor and saw an immediate improvement. (SDN-6) In its defense I was incredibly pleased the initial accuracy of it at 100 yards, in the cold at Rebel's shop.

    Things calmed down long enough for me to see what this rifle is capable of at 300 yards. The following a target at 300 yards an adjustment up then back down got me right on target.

    The winds died off just long enough for me to pull of this little beauty.

    The following was a ladder test of Barnes 127gr LRX and Nosler 129gr ABLR, both used Hornady virgin brass ,CCI 450 primers, and CFE 223.


    The 127gr LRX. This is what not to do. I may have started at max pressure. I was using the super chrono and wasn't able to monitor the velocity as I was shooting. If anyone is interested in trying this combination, I'd suggest starting below 28grs.
    Charge (gr) Velocity (fps)
    29..... 2221.0
    29.3 ..... 2237.0
    29.6 .....2263.0
    29.9 .....2257.0
    30.2 .....2319.0
    30.5 .....2378.0
    30.8 .....2322.0
    31.1..... 2421.0
    31.4..... 2375.0

    The 129gr Nosler ABLR
    Charge (gr) Velocity (fps)
    28.4..... 2208.0
    28.7..... 2227.0
    29..... 2257.0
    29.3..... 2251.0
    29.6..... 2260.0
    29.9..... 2303.0
    30.2..... 2309.0

    I may have something at 29.3gr to 29.9gr. 30.2gr was max fill at 2.294 COL. 30.5gr was so compressed the press caved in the nose during loading.

    I won't even display the Nosler 123gr CC OW target. The results weren't acceptable at all. It also used Hornady virgin brass ,CCI 450 primers, and CFE 223.
    Charge (gr) Velocity (fps) STD Dev # Samples
    30..... 2344.0..... 30.5..... 3
    30.3..... 2379.3..... 6.7..... 3
    30.6..... 2396.7..... 27.1..... 3
    30.9..... 2413.0..... 23.1..... 3
    31.2..... 2455.7.... 10.2..... 3
    31.5..... 2477.7..... 20.4..... 3
    31.8..... 2499.7..... 16.5..... 3
    32.1..... 2534.7..... 21.0..... 3
    32.4..... 2526.0..... ..... 1
    32.7..... 2588.0..... ..... 1

    It was obvious (at least to me) I had hit the pressure limit at 32.4grs and the velocity data backed it up.
    "Those who sacrifice liberty for security, deserve neither." Benjamin Franklin
  • Kikn
    Warrior
    • Nov 2011
    • 689

    #2
    I've had a very similar experience with my aac suppressor. I've found that with less pressure is more accurate. But standard Hornady loads I get crazy very different points compared to it being off. And it doesn't group as well. I ci use under powered load, the POI is pretty close.

    It wasn't like that when I first started using it. I haven't cleaned it yet. I pretty much just stopped using it because it was useless.

    Comment

    • cory
      Chieftain
      • Jun 2012
      • 2987

      #3
      That's what I'm afraid off. This suppressor was to expensive to be a paper weight.
      "Those who sacrifice liberty for security, deserve neither." Benjamin Franklin

      Comment

      • am4966
        Chieftain
        • Jul 2014
        • 1036

        #4
        Hopefully you'll get the results your looking for with the can when it's attached to a 11.5" Lilja barrel. Since I'm hoping to use 100gr Barnes and the 129gr ABLR in my 12.5" for hunting, however things could change.
        Last edited by am4966; 04-24-2015, 01:27 AM. Reason: Added more info
        12.5" SBR Grendel - Need Barrel
        Surge - Rugged Suppressor
        Been a fan of the Grendel from the very beginning and haven't second guessed that choice one time.

        Aim small, miss small!

        Comment

        • Variable
          Chieftain
          • Mar 2011
          • 2403

          #5
          Originally posted by cory View Post

          I took a trip to the range today for the fist time since late last fall. After about an hour of shooting, I was about ready to tear my rifle down and rebuild her making sure everything was torqued. It was the first time I've used my suppressor on a warmer day (72F). I suspect the suppressor heating up was affecting my accuracy. I'll need to do further testing on a better day to verify.

          I discarded the suppressor and saw an immediate improvement. (SDN-6) In its defense I was incredibly pleased the initial accuracy of it at 100 yards, in the cold at Rebel's shop.




          The 129gr Nosler ABLR
          Charge (gr) Velocity (fps)
          28.4..... 2208.0
          28.7..... 2227.0
          29..... 2257.0
          29.3..... 2251.0
          29.6..... 2260.0
          29.9..... 2303.0
          30.2..... 2309.0

          I may have something at 29.3gr to 29.9gr. 30.2gr was max fill at 2.294 COL. 30.5gr was so compressed the press caved in the nose during loading.
          Suppressor: Perhaps mirage issues?

          129 ABLR: Thank you very much for sharing your data Cory! That's good stuff. What barrel length is that from?
          Life member NRA, SAF, GOA, WVSRPA (and VFW). Also member WVCDL. Join NOW!!!!!
          We either hang together on this, or we'll certainly HANG separately.....

          Comment

          • cory
            Chieftain
            • Jun 2012
            • 2987

            #6
            I recently added a TAB Gear cover to the suppressor. I don't think it's mirage, but I think the cover could be exasperating the heating issue.

            It's a 16" Bartlein Barrel from Precision Firearms.
            I set out to build a 16" Grendel back in the spring of 2013. Not to spoil the ending, it seems to have been well worth the wait. This rifle truly has been a long time coming. It took me down a journey that saw many detours and evolutions. Initially it was set to be a standard Templar barrel built around a seekins billet


            From what I've read the ABLR is more susceptible to its jump to lands (JTL), than the particular charge. I'm going to use the 29.3gr charge and play with the COL. Then I'll fine tune the charge.

            The 127gr LRX is going to be useless to me at 2200fps. If the guys are interested, I'll donate what I have to the cause. I think the LRX in a 110gr to 115gr will be great.
            "Those who sacrifice liberty for security, deserve neither." Benjamin Franklin

            Comment

            • Savage Shooter
              Warrior
              • Dec 2014
              • 241

              #7
              Originally posted by cory View Post
              I took a trip to the range today for the fist time since late last fall.
              There is your problem right there! Why didn't you get out and shoot more? You live in AL, where, outside of mid-February this year (granted it was a whopper snowstorm), I don't think the area got much snow/cold weather - certainly no worse than Charlotte. I think I "forced" myself to shoot at least two and sometimes three weekends a month, with various firearms. I'd bet most of our horde brethren from waay up north got out more than you did. So, "muscle memory rust and rot" can be blamed, LOL.....
              My "6.5" = 24" AA Overwatch upper 1/9 twist, NC based US Tactical lower, standard A4 6 position stock, AR Gold Trigger, JPS SCS buffer, Vortex 6-24 x 50 FFP PST with EBR-2C MOA reticle

              Comment

              • Variable
                Chieftain
                • Mar 2011
                • 2403

                #8
                Whew! Okay, cool. I was worried that velocity was from a longer barrel.

                I was hoping for 2300fps from a 12.5" tube, but looking at your data it doesn't look like it'll be happening. Oh well. If it'll shoot well, it'd still fly pretty darn well at 2200fps from a shorter tube. Hopefully I can get 2200 from a 12.5" tube.

                I wish we could soak the CFE223 in some nitro and pick up another 100fps.
                Life member NRA, SAF, GOA, WVSRPA (and VFW). Also member WVCDL. Join NOW!!!!!
                We either hang together on this, or we'll certainly HANG separately.....

                Comment

                • Variable
                  Chieftain
                  • Mar 2011
                  • 2403

                  #9
                  When you filled your cases, did you try a drop tube and/or vibrate them?
                  Life member NRA, SAF, GOA, WVSRPA (and VFW). Also member WVCDL. Join NOW!!!!!
                  We either hang together on this, or we'll certainly HANG separately.....

                  Comment

                  • cory
                    Chieftain
                    • Jun 2012
                    • 2987

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Savage Shooter View Post
                    There is your problem right there! Why didn't you get out and shoot more? You live in AL, where, outside of mid-February this year (granted it was a whopper snowstorm), I don't think the area got much snow/cold weather - certainly no worse than Charlotte. I think I "forced" myself to shoot at least two and sometimes three weekends a month, with various firearms. I'd bet most of our horde brethren from waay up north got out more than you did. So, "muscle memory rust and rot" can be blamed, LOL.....
                    Life happens. HAHA I started in the prone and thought that was part of the problem. After about 20 rounds I jumped up on the bench and under a sand bag to rule out my rust. It didn't get much better.

                    This was one of the worst winters for us in a LONG time. We got more than our fair share of ice and snow.

                    Originally posted by Variable View Post
                    Whew! Okay, cool. I was worried that velocity was from a longer barrel.

                    I was hoping for 2300fps from a 12.5" tube, but looking at your data it doesn't look like it'll be happening. Oh well. If it'll shoot well, it'd still fly pretty darn well at 2200fps from a shorter tube. Hopefully I can get 2200 from a 12.5" tube.

                    I wish we could soak the CFE223 in some nitro and pick up another 100fps.
                    I think there's enough case capacity if we could load out to ~2.4". We'd need a new receiver set for that.
                    I'm posting a thread here for a discussion that was brought up in another thread, but seemed to have gotten lost. http://www.65grendel.com/forum/showthread.php?9230-Precision-Firearms-is-working-on-the-First-batch-of-Side-Charge-Upper-Receivers I suggest to Mark at PF that it'd be the greatest thing since the invent of the


                    I'd really like to try some VV N540 with some of these longer bullets. If I could find any.

                    Originally posted by Variable View Post
                    When you filled your cases, did you try a drop tube and/or vibrate them?
                    I guess I'm still a novice reloader. I've never done this and I'm not sure how to or what tools I'll need.
                    "Those who sacrifice liberty for security, deserve neither." Benjamin Franklin

                    Comment

                    • biodsl
                      Chieftain
                      • Aug 2011
                      • 1718

                      #11
                      Originally posted by cory View Post
                      I guess I'm still a novice reloader. I've never done this and I'm not sure how to or what tools I'll need.
                      Check this out at around the 12:50 mark. A nice re-purpose!
                      Paul Peloquin

                      Did government credibility die of Covid or with Covid?

                      Comment

                      • lead chucker
                        Warrior
                        • Sep 2014
                        • 241

                        #12
                        Mine is very accurate with my cyclone. But I did work the load up with the suppressor on it. Just play with it some more, work you load with the suppressor. Good luck and happy shooting. We all need to shoot more I know I do.

                        Comment

                        • cory
                          Chieftain
                          • Jun 2012
                          • 2987

                          #13
                          Originally posted by biodsl View Post
                          Check this out at around the 12:50 mark. A nice re-purpose!
                          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSChoYoGKq8
                          Good stuff! Thanks!!!

                          Originally posted by lead chucker View Post
                          Mine is very accurate with my cyclone. But I did work the load up with the suppressor on it. Just play with it some more, work you load with the suppressor. Good luck and happy shooting. We all need to shoot more I know I do.
                          I'm going to play with it more before I render any verdict on the suppressor. A POI shift is fine, but if this thing is degrading accuracy with factory loads it'll become an expensive paper weight.
                          "Those who sacrifice liberty for security, deserve neither." Benjamin Franklin

                          Comment

                          • bwaites
                            Moderator
                            • Mar 2011
                            • 4445

                            #14
                            Cory,

                            Anything you hang on the end of the barrel will possibly cause issues. Suppressors are notorious for that, but I know of rifles that shoot great with the muzzle brake, but not without, as well. Anything you add to the length changes barrel harmonics, and you can bet that when you hang a big ol' hunk of metal out there that is essentially a funny bell with baffles you will see all kinds of effects. What is amazing to me is that some companies are able to design their suppressors so that they don't have much POI effect, but that is the exception, not the rule.

                            One of the amazing things about the Hornady factory load is that it seems to shoot well out of just about every rifle, no matter the barrel length, but it was developed for non-suppressed rifles, and you may have run into the place where it doesn't run. There are a few other factory loads like that, Federal Match .308 for example, but they are the exception, not the rule.

                            Most guys who run suppressors develop a load specifically for that situation, and I'm betting you will have to do so as well. We just don't have enough suppressed experience with the Grendel across the board to make a lot of headway regarding possible loads.

                            Comment

                            • Savage Shooter
                              Warrior
                              • Dec 2014
                              • 241

                              #15
                              Originally posted by cory View Post

                              I guess I'm still a novice reloader. I've never done this and I'm not sure how to or what tools I'll need.
                              I trickle charge/weigh all my rifle loads into a pan, then dump the pan into a funnel. When I start to get close to compressed loads, I switch funnels and I use the Forster Blue Ribbon Powder Funnel with Long Drop Tube. http://www.midwayusa.com/product/293...ProductFinding Believe it or not, the extra few inches the powder falls into the case is enough to give it enough extra velocity (gravity driven) so that the powder settles deeper and more uniformly into the case.
                              My "6.5" = 24" AA Overwatch upper 1/9 twist, NC based US Tactical lower, standard A4 6 position stock, AR Gold Trigger, JPS SCS buffer, Vortex 6-24 x 50 FFP PST with EBR-2C MOA reticle

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X