Are all Grendel extractors interchangeable?

[Bronsonburner]

Extractor in my PSA type II bolt broke the other day at the range. Has about 800 rounds on it. Am I OK to order any other type II extractor and expect a drop in fit? Thanks in advance.

[lazyengineer]

I did.

In theory.... mostly yes. Sort of. Others will be able to say better than me, but for a time there were two standards for Grendel bolt and chamber related stuff; though it seemed to have settled on just one standard a long time ago, so unless you're getting used or really-old-stock, then yea, it probably will work.

For me, I had a PSA one snap. It was interesting to see just how paper-thin the metal is under the groove, the only thing really holding the extractor together at Grendel dimensions, is the tab thing where a bolt-lug would otherwise be. PSA ultimately warrentteed me an entire replacement BCG, but in the meantime, I replaced the extractor with a Black Rifle Arms one, that seemed cost effective. Been running that one ever since, seems to be working fine.

I did pick up a few Red X arms ones as emergency ones that I tape inside my pistol grip; But I can't say I recommend them. Some of the more experienced guys here who know a lot more than me, very actively DON"T recommend them.
I do note the RedX ones don't have the inside corners relieved, which apparently causes problems, so I touched those points up with a precision file. No idea if they actually work; I just picked them up as very low-cost emergency field repair units.

[grayfox]

In general yes, a type 2 (0.136 bolt face depth) for a type 2. There is a thinner-depth extractor (0.125 face depth) (or type 1 as they are called), this one is a no-no except for rifles whose chambers are cut for it.
Now I say in general b/c of course mfg methods and QC can differ. I believe Mark from PF has good extractors.
Wherever you settle, also consider having one complete bolt in hand as a spare for such events. Something's gonna break.
BFT has his six5arms in the vendor area and he sells probably the dynamite standard bolt, great price, quality, go look there and pick up your spare.

[A5BLASTER]

Extractor in my PSA type II bolt broke the other day at the range. Has about 800 rounds on it. Am I OK to order any other type II extractor and expect a drop in fit? Thanks in advance.

The best to get is the one sold by Alexander arms.

[Bronsonburner]

Thanks for the advice. Will try to get a few AA ones.

[grayfox]

One more helpful thing. Some new extractors may need to have their little tooth-corners smoothed down -- just a tad! -- to prevent gouging into the brass at extraction. You'll know if you see the effects.

[Mesa1978]

The best to get is the one sold by Alexander arms.

+1

[BluntForceTrauma]

The best to get is the one sold by Alexander arms.

I'm in the awkward position of tooting my own horn here....

My MONSTER bolts and the bolts of Alexander Arms are made by the same manufacturer. Check the details of the machining. See that little semi-circle groove just behind each lug? The same.

My bolts are nitrided. The AA bolt is phosphated.

Compare prices. I take care of my fellow Horde members, no matter how Vile and Unwashed. 'Nuff sed.

[VASCAR2]

https://www.blackriflearms.com/-65-Grendel-Extractor-_p_297.html

[A5BLASTER]

I'm in the awkward position of tooting my own horn here....

My MONSTER bolts and the bolts of Alexander Arms are made by the same manufacturer. Check the details of the machining. See that little semi-circle groove just behind each lug? The same.

My bolts are nitrided. The AA bolt is phosphated.

Compare prices. I take care of my fellow Horde members, no matter how Vile and Unwashed. 'Nuff sed.

Yes sir your bolts are great. I have several. But the OP was looking for just an extractor not the whole bolt. So I didn't think too include the sixfive bolts.

[BluntForceTrauma]

For just an extractor, the Black Rifle Arms and the AA extractors are the same. Can't speak to the OP's PSA bolt, however. If it was MY money, I'd risk it on the theory they can't be THAT different.

[FRB6.5]

I'm in the awkward position of tooting my own horn here....

My MONSTER bolts and the bolts of Alexander Arms are made by the same manufacturer. Check the details of the machining. See that little semi-circle groove just behind each lug? The same.

My bolts are nitrided. The AA bolt is phosphated.

Compare prices. I take care of my fellow Horde members, no matter how Vile and Unwashed. 'Nuff sed.

I wish there was a like feature for the forums +1

File that sharp corner off in the extractor channel and your bolts are perfect.

[BluntForceTrauma]

I wish there was a like feature for the forums +1. File that sharp corner off in the extractor channel and your bolts are perfect.

You know, that IS a real issue I gotta bring up with the mfr.

[Bronz]

One more helpful thing. Some new extractors may need to have their little tooth-corners smoothed down -- just a tad! -- to prevent gouging into the brass at extraction. You'll know if you see the effects.

Yes I have seen this.

[southpaw]

You know, that IS a real issue I gotta bring up with the mfr.

I had this issue with a new Monster bolt. After fixing the extractor it was GTG