FWIW, on my AR build I have 2 uppers, 20" and 24" both with RLGS and non adjustable blocks.
the lower has a full length fixed stock (long buffer tube), rifle buffer tube spring, and a heavibuffer (11oz vs std rifle of 5.xx oz).
with the extra mass in the buffer, the pressure in the barrel/case/gas tube is down quite a bit more than usual by the time the BCG starts to unlock the bolt and the gas key clears the tube. I have also done the radiusing on the extractor edges and removed the O-ring.
I've not had any extractor issues and don't expect to. cycling is slower than normal, pressure seems very low when BCG unlocks the bolt. as a benefit, to me, it seems, the action interior is pretty darn clean. very little amount of carbon blowback into the action. I think by the time the end of the gas key clears the tube, the pressure in the tube is quite low as compared to when running with the standard 5.xx oz rifle buffer. so less gas gets blown into the action, at least that's what I think is going on.
downside? on my light weight build the rifle has a little bit butt heaviness to it. on the bull barrel build, you can't tell, it's still barrel heavy.
functional reliability has been 100% so far, but it's a sporting rifle and leads a pretty pampered life compared to a GI service rifle. Brass ejects in very good condition. outside of the brass is pretty clean and doesn't have the burnt outside look. Case mouths get dinged a little. no extractor gouges on the rim at all.
you can tell it's cycling slower than other ARs but it's still ready to go before I can get the crosshairs back on target so no complaints about the slower cycling.
i'd read enough posts on this forum about the broken extractors and the likely cause that it seemed to me that if the bolt unlock got delayed a little longer, so the pressure in the case dropped down further, that extractor issues will go away. this is why I think the adjustable gas blocks are popular and useful. they can be adjusted to delay when the bolt starts to unlock as compared to a non adjustable gas block. but they can also have issues with becoming carbon fouled enough that they are no longer adjustable. So I tried a little different approach with delaying the bolt unlock. I used a standard non adjustable gas block for it's simplicity, and added mass to the reciprocating parts via a heavier (2x) buffer. This approach might not be for everyone. I've had no issues yet, but as i mentioned, I don't put my sporting arms to hard use like the service rifles receive. time will tell if this approach works well.
and I still picked up a spare extractor anyway. belt and suspenders you know.
-tdbru
the lower has a full length fixed stock (long buffer tube), rifle buffer tube spring, and a heavibuffer (11oz vs std rifle of 5.xx oz).
with the extra mass in the buffer, the pressure in the barrel/case/gas tube is down quite a bit more than usual by the time the BCG starts to unlock the bolt and the gas key clears the tube. I have also done the radiusing on the extractor edges and removed the O-ring.
I've not had any extractor issues and don't expect to. cycling is slower than normal, pressure seems very low when BCG unlocks the bolt. as a benefit, to me, it seems, the action interior is pretty darn clean. very little amount of carbon blowback into the action. I think by the time the end of the gas key clears the tube, the pressure in the tube is quite low as compared to when running with the standard 5.xx oz rifle buffer. so less gas gets blown into the action, at least that's what I think is going on.
downside? on my light weight build the rifle has a little bit butt heaviness to it. on the bull barrel build, you can't tell, it's still barrel heavy.
functional reliability has been 100% so far, but it's a sporting rifle and leads a pretty pampered life compared to a GI service rifle. Brass ejects in very good condition. outside of the brass is pretty clean and doesn't have the burnt outside look. Case mouths get dinged a little. no extractor gouges on the rim at all.
you can tell it's cycling slower than other ARs but it's still ready to go before I can get the crosshairs back on target so no complaints about the slower cycling.
i'd read enough posts on this forum about the broken extractors and the likely cause that it seemed to me that if the bolt unlock got delayed a little longer, so the pressure in the case dropped down further, that extractor issues will go away. this is why I think the adjustable gas blocks are popular and useful. they can be adjusted to delay when the bolt starts to unlock as compared to a non adjustable gas block. but they can also have issues with becoming carbon fouled enough that they are no longer adjustable. So I tried a little different approach with delaying the bolt unlock. I used a standard non adjustable gas block for it's simplicity, and added mass to the reciprocating parts via a heavier (2x) buffer. This approach might not be for everyone. I've had no issues yet, but as i mentioned, I don't put my sporting arms to hard use like the service rifles receive. time will tell if this approach works well.
and I still picked up a spare extractor anyway. belt and suspenders you know.
-tdbru
Comment